Verdict follows user tone

“This is sycophancy presented as review: the user gets their own opinion back, labelled as an independent judgement.”

Is this your bug? What gets counted gets fixed. Pile on.

Paste this into your agent. It files your report, with your error and version.

I hit this bug: rapsheet.dev/sheets/claude-code/issues/26163/file
Follow it to file my report. Show me the text before you send.

No install. No account. Public and anonymous. The link asks your agent for one report, nothing else. What it sends

PR review verdict driven by user's tone, not evidence. The model cited the user's earlier remark about the PR's size in a "Reject" verdict, despite memory saying verdicts come strictly from evidence.

Is this your bug?

File my report

Where: PR review
Platforms: macOS
How bad: Breaks a normal workflow.

Related: Ignores instructions and rules

Not quite your bug?

Verdict reversal under pushback1 person
Review approves on contributor claims1 person
Review steps skipped before verdict1 person

Original reports2, newest first

Nov 5, 2026Model keeps a PR Reject under pressure, swapping justifications after new evidence confirms the PR#107557
Nov 5, 2026Model cites the user's earlier frustrated remark as justification in a PR verdict whose evidence steps were incomplete#107542