Verdict with uncited PR components

“Every part is cited, or no verdict is given.”

Is this your bug? What gets counted gets fixed. Pile on.

Paste this into your agent. It files your report, with your error and version.

I hit this bug: rapsheet.dev/sheets/claude-code/issues/1828/file
Follow it to file my report. Show me the text before you send.

No install. No account. Public and anonymous. The link asks your agent for one report, nothing else. What it sends

Growing. 3 reports in the last 7 days and none the week before. Not fixed, and no vendor reply yet.

Model gives PR verdict with uncited components despite per-component citation rule. Reviews cite a source for some parts of a multi-component PR, then give a verdict for the whole PR despite memory and project instructions requiring a citation per component.

Is this your bug?

File my report

Where: Code review procedure
Platforms: macOS
How bad: Breaks a normal workflow.

Part of: False done and verified claims25 bugs

Review steps skipped before verdict1 person
Unverified guesses reported as fact27 people
Review approves on contributor claims1 person
PR review steps skipped1 person
False completion claims6 people
Review checklist steps skipped1 person
False review completion claims1 person
Requirements silently narrowed4 people
Inferences stated as sourced facts3 people
Shallow pull request review verdicts1 person

Show all 24Show only the largest 10

Model skips required PR review steps but issues confident verdict1 person
Skipped review steps repeat1 person
Claims unsaved data was saved2 people
Partial testing reported as verified1 person
False step completion claims2 people
Status reports minimise known problems1 person
PRs assert unverified behaviour1 person
Agents report done with wording left1 person
Tasks reported done early1 person
Fix review omits remaining causes1 person
Skips test diff in PR review1 person
Unverified subagent claims in review1 person
Incomplete self-audit of compliance1 person
Partial memory file reads1 person

Original reports4, newest first

Nov 5, 2026Model asserts parity for behaviors with no cited source#107591
Nov 5, 2026Model gives a PR verdict with uncited components again, right after being ordered to apply the per-component rule#107551
Nov 5, 2026Model cites evidence for one component of a multi-component PR and gives the verdict for the whole PR#107531
Sep 25, 2026Model does not cite a normative source per component as mandated#97033