Its theme's rank, 14 days: 18 on the Codex sheet
18 people reported
All time, since Oct 7, including 1 thumbs-up on GitHub.
Direct approval rejected as untrusted
“Auto-review misclassifies direct user approval as untrusted history when sending to an existing task”
Is this your bug? What gets counted gets fixed. Pile on.
Paste this into your agent. It files your report, with your error and version.
I hit this bug: rapsheet.dev/sheets/codex/issues/10417/file Follow it to file my report. Show me the text before you send.
No install. No account. Public and anonymous. The link asks your agent for one report, nothing else. What it sends
Auto-review rejects direct user approval as untrusted history. Sends to existing chats via send_message_to_thread are blocked even after the human types approval directly in the same chat.
Is this your bug?
File my report- Where
- Auto-review
- Versions
- 0.162.0 to 26.1023.51421
- Platforms
- macOS, Windows
- How bad
- Breaks a normal workflow. Some reports say it blocks them completely.
Part of: Delegated task approval not recognized8 bugs
- Forwarded approval rejected17 people
- /approve command unavailable8 people
- Relayed approval rejected2 people
- Delegated owner consent rejected2 people
- Forwarded authorization rejected2 people
- Auto-review rejects delegated commands2 people
- Auto-review cites superseded restriction2 people
Original reports17, newest first
- Codex Desktop automatic review fails to recognize native recurring user authorizationOn GitHub#60135
- Auto-review rates explicit user approval as unknown; desktop has no available per-action overrideOn GitHub#58855
- Desktop: authorized bounded worker dispatch denied as untrusted; original denial cannot be locatedOn GitHub#58573
- [Windows][Auto-review] Direct human permission to message existing worker rejected as untrusted; /approve unavailableOn GitHub#58570
- Desktop Auto-review rejects explicit user authorization; no manual override or feedback entry availableOn GitHub#58501
- Approval review treats direct user authorization as untrusted transcriptOn GitHub#58401
- Auto-review rejects direct human authorization as untrusted transcript; /approve unavailable in macOS app 26.1023.51421On GitHub#58062
- Windows desktop: cross-thread owner authorization rejected; effective execution rules not observableOn GitHub#57349
- Desktop automatic approval repeatedly rejects cross-thread coordination despite verified user authorizationOn GitHub#56791
- Auto-review rejects direct user approval as “untrusted transcript evidence,On GitHub#56653
Show all 17Show only the newest 10
- Automatic review rejects explicit user authorization as untrusted history.On GitHub#55514
- [Windows][Auto-review] Direct approval in affected desktop chat treated as untrusted retained transcript for local chat handoffOn GitHub#55098
- Windows desktop auto-review rejects direct human authorization for cross-chat reports; prior same-project calls succeededOn GitHub#54962
- [Windows Desktop] Direct user approval becomes untrusted after history restoration (history_missing_checkpoint)On GitHub#54456
- Auto-review treats direct approval after a referenced chat as untrusted history, blocking migration and pushOn GitHub#53430
- Auto-review misclassifies direct user approval as untrusted history when sending to an existing taskOn GitHub#53037
- Codex App side conversation treats fresh user authorization as untrusted historyOn GitHub#51871